It's time to turn out the lights

throng-logoBlogging has been part of our household since 2002 but it hasn’t always been about television.

While Rachel was still lecturing statistics at Auckland University and writing courses to help the media better use stats in their reporting, the world of blogging was beginning to take off. After 9/11, there was an influx of new political commentators who took to the web to voice their opinions on the war on terror and it was these blogs that helped a lot of people realise that anyone could build an audience and engage with them like never before.

It was around then that we met Darren Rowse. Rachel helped him as he developed his first blog but it was toward the end 2003 that something interesting happened. Darren had written a post about Guy Sebastian and the Australian Idol competition and on the night of the finale, his blog went nuts. There was very little else online and all of a sudden, thousands of people had found his post and were talking about the finale and the result of Guy winning.

This got us all to thinking. What if rather than having a single post about something, we created an entire blog for just one topic? Swedish Namespedia. And with that Idolblog was born.

Idolblog was unprecedented in New Zealand television history. Pre the world of Facebook and twitter, it was the first online community built around a TV series here. From the network’s perspective, we were nothing more than a pain in the ass as we had more control over the publicity of the show than TVNZ did, but for the fans, Idolblog was just awesome.

Recorded on a Friday night in West Auckland, those who had tickets to the live recording would come home and jump online and spill the beans about who sang what. While the network were terrified by the thought of their expensive production being spoiled for the masses, in reality, Idolblog created more hype and excitement than any ad campaign could have bought them.

Idolblog became the go-to destination for everything to do with the show and once the finals arrived, the media attention began and we were sought after for our commentary and insight and were featured right across the media from The Listener to Metro, along with TV, Radio, Newspapers and the women’s mags.

There were thousands and thousands of young kids who were enormous fans of Ben Lummis and Michael Murphy and they were all voicing their opinion about the show on Idolblog. Many of these kids from all around New Zealand have become long term friends who we’ve remained in touch with over the years, some of who we’ve even travelled overseas with together to attend concerts. Our kids are all grown up now and we’ve been privileged to see some of them become wonderful teachers, and lawyers, and food technologists, and international TV stars. After more than a decade, the Idolblog family is still strong and is full of people who have made lifelong friends that they wouldn’t have met other than around New Zealand Idol.

Eventually, TVNZ got around to setting up their own “official” forums but they were nothing in comparison.

2004 was very big year. While Idolblog went on to win Best Youth Website at the annual Netguide Web Awards, Darren and I had another project we wanted to collaborate on, an Olympic Games blog. I developed some software to run alongside the content management system we were using that would generate pages based on the results of each event. This provided us with unprecedented speed in publishing results and in the majority of cases, we had the results of each event and medal winners online before any of the major Olympics websites including the official IOC one, the BBC and NBC websites. I also created an embeddable Medal Table widget that allowed any other blog or website to add it to their sidebar which linked back to our blog. This was used by hundreds of different websites including a number of international mainstream media outlets’ websites.

Darren and I switched our respective timezones to be on Athens time, with me in New Zealand and he in Melbourne, we spent nearly two solid weeks covering the games and producing thousands of pages of content that were being read by 250,000+ people every day. It was phenomenal, but only the beginning. The link love that we benefited from meant that, at the time, we could pretty much launch and link to a new blog on any topic we’d be guaranteed a top 10 search ranking, usually first.

The following year we launched another site. StreetTalk was an online community for the fans of Shortland Street. This was another exceptional project full of the most ardent fans you can imagine. Again, it was a thorn in the side of TVNZ who were struggling to come to grips with how to deal with people who were passionate about their content. The correct response would have been to embrace it and work with it for the benefit of the audience but sadly that was never the case.

During the off season of Idol, I blogged seasons of American Idol, Canadian Idol and Australian Idol on separate Idolblog sites we set up for each region. The US site did incredibly well. There is nothing quite like 20,000 people reading your work every hour.

We also discovered that in the off season of NZ Idol, the Idolbloggers wanted to discuss other TV shows. It was from here that Throng was born in late 2006.

One of the early highlights was being invited by Sir Paul Holmes to have coffee with him and explain the world of blogging to him. After our lengthy chat, he enthusiastically took me for a quick spin in his newly imported, luxury car.

Over the next 9 years, Throng produced more than 65,000 pages of content which was read by approximately 1.5 million people. The most read pieces of content include news about Canterbury University’s WASP for Sky Sport’s cricket coverage, The Top 10 Reasons you Shouldn’t Get Igloo, The Shortland Street Star sex tape scandal and The X Factor Conspiracy Theory.

We’ve broken a number of stories, many of them around how programs have rated, but also things like the return of Dancing with the Stars to TV3 and the Short Poppies/Netflix/NZ On Air story.

The thing I’m most proud of though, was our coverage of the 2009 Qantas Film and Television awards. Earlier that year I had worked the red carpet at the Australian equivalent and came home determined to treat our industry awards with the same level of excitement and respect. Hamish, Ben and Dayna did an outstanding job.

Air New Zealand helped us get to Australia to interview the cast of Glee too.

From this last year, there are two highlights that stand out to me. Firstly, hosting Neil Hunt, one of the executives from Netflix, during his visit for their launch. Secondly, the first junket I’ve ever done which was to Sydney with Samsung for the launch of their new SUHD TVs.

Earlier this week Bernard Hickey said this:

In reality, Throng has never really survived off advertising and has only survived due to my own subsidising of it. The idea of ad-funded blogs has, in reality, never really existed in New Zealand.

The ideal solution for bloggers would have been to have had an agency that represented all blogs to advertisers. I attempted on a number of occasions to make this happen and bring bloggers together for a bigger cause but unfortunately there are too many people who would rather spend their time hating each other.

In reality though, the advertising agencies in New Zealand have never embraced the power of blogs and have done more to harm the potential that independent publishers have than help. In regards to Throng, there are cases where, despite being instructed by their client to book advertising on local websites, the agencies have refused and booked campaigns with foreign websites, like The Daily Mail instead. The number of times we have worked directly with a client to develop a campaign only to be derailed or stonewalled by an agency is incredible.

The biggest irony though, is the way agencies value the audience of blogs. The PR side will happily give you whatever they can for free which they bill their clients for while the advertising side sees no value at all. After more than a decade, it is clear to me that ad agencies only care about themselves. When it comes to clients, the only care they have about them is in not losing their business.

So where to now? Rachel, who hasn’t had any involvement with the running of Throng for a while now, is running her own web design business which provides services to professional bloggers, mostly overseas. While I may be biased, her insights make her one of the best in her field which is evident by some fairly prestigious names in her list of clients.

As for me, I have a number of new things I’m working on. Right now, I have a small, recently planted, sixty vine vineyard that needs some attention as well as four young children who are pretty excited that Christmas is nearly here. Who knows, I might even spend some time at Quail West Naples Homes. This is certainly not the end of my media career but I’m done working for free.

On that note, if anyone would like to say thanks, you are welcome to do so here:





In closing, I’d like to thank everyone who has contributed to the conversation over the years. For those who have engaged, made me laugh, made me angry, and participated in sharing a love of television, I salute you.

I’m very humbled by the number of emails, calls and personal messages that I’ve received over the last week, particularly from those both currently and previously from within the industry.

If you’d like to stay in touch, feel free to follow me on twitter: @reganjcunliffe

Subscribe to our mailing list

About the author

Regan is one of the co-founders of Throng Media.
If they’re on, I’m usually watching Game of Thrones, The Walking Dead, 24, Battlestar Galactica, The X Factor, Survivor, House of Cards, Mad Men and the NRL.

More from this author »

  • Dave Ian Batten

    So, is Throng shutting down?

  • Kyle Wadsworth

    Goodbye Throng – thanks for being there to host the first-ever review of TVNZ Ondemand way back in 2007. It gave me quite a ride.

    • Regan Cunliffe
      • Kyle Wadsworth

        And there it is..haha

        • Jay

          How’s Liz these days, Kyle?

          • Kyle Wadsworth

            Who knows, who cares!

          • Jay

            I thought she was your BFF?

          • Kyle Wadsworth

            Never not even once. Ain’t nobody got time for that

          • Jay

            Really? I seem to recall you defending her quite vigorously on the forerunner to Throng – the IdolBlog forums. Someone (rightly) gave her hell and you said “just leave her alone and no one gets hurt” (or something like that).

          • For Jay

            Excuse you, but what gives you the right to come on here and bash someone you probably don’t even know on a public forum? Live and let live and worry about cleaning your own webs out of your closet.

          • Jay

            The person he was defending was not really in a position to be defended. Free country, isn’t it?

  • John McCready

    Thanks for the site, it will be missed. Go well.

    • Regan Cunliffe

      Thanks John.

  • epistaxis

    will miss this site..luv reading the ratings and having my 10 cents worth of opinon
    (and will miss having to re type “throng” everytime, because my r key is munted and I always end up with “thong”..!)
    cheers regan

  • Dave Ian Batten

    I will miss Throng! I’ve enjoyed every minute of it.

    I want to apologize for the dick head comments I’ve made over the years. I love TV.

    Regan, you rock! Good luck with your future ventures, and hope to see you on another website.

    God bless!

  • K

    Good luck Regan

  • End of an era

    I really am quite sad about all this, I have spent so much of my time on this site reading posts and its comments, even making my own comments. It has been a great platform for likeminded people (a stretch, lol), I have come here twice a day everyday, (even on the weekends when I new nothing really got posted) for years it’s been part of my routine, and with Regan off, the site really is ending. I have said it before Regan and I now follow you on Twitter, but all the best from H.Lua/H.M./nightline think those were my only screen names I’m sure.

  • Harrison

    Goodbye Regan and thanks for all the articles and everything over the years! All the best!

  • Robyn Gallagher

    It’s been a blast! The Idol days were full of fun and drama, from being hauled into my manager’s officer at TVNZ for daring to write hilarious recaps about NZ Idol (they eventually came to see things from my points of view), to the hilarious-in-retrospect “So Damn Controversial” saga. Idol Blog and Throng were very necessary and was exactly what was needed in the world of New Zealand television fandom.

    It’s sad to see Throng wrapping up, but it’s left a legacy that will live on. <3

  • Jayne Lewis

    I haven’t spent much time on Throng, but I will never forget all the fun times had on idolblog.com and the people I met – online, in person, and on those weird Telecom screen things at the malls! Thanks for the memories guys 🙂

    • Kyle Wadsworth

      Those screen things! I was so jealous when you guys went to those (too flash for New Plymouth lol).
      -TuiKiwi

  • Guest

    Unless the bill for renewing the domain name is coming up, if I was you I’d just keep Throng open, along with the daily ‘tv talk’ post, and let members of the public make their own posts about TV stuff. That would require very minimal input from you (I gather, judging by some of the comments that get posted, that you don’t moderate). If the site keeps getting traffic and enough people are commenting, then maybe look to sell it as a going concern – you might make a bit of money from all the work you’ve put into it over the years? You could sell it through a business broker or an auction site. You could even offer your domain name for sale, and get the traffic that currently comes here to go somewhere else – a savvy TV or media company would surely be interested in that. What will happen to the Canada and Australia sites – are they operated independently?

    • Jay

      That sounds like a good idea.

  • Jane Wrightson

    Good luck Regan and all the best

  • Joshhill96

    Thanks Regan, This has always been the fist place to go to all things media, love the commentaries and articles and the news about broadcasters and channels. Will be missed heaps! Good luck with future endeavours!

  • MyView5

    I was always writing to the TV Guide asking them why they gave prominent listing space to networks that rated low. One day the editor asked me to front up with statistics to back my complaint so I pointed them in Throng’s direction. Shortly after that they relegated the listings of a lesser station and promoted a higher rating one.

    Larry Williams on NewstalkZB is always quoting stats from Throng.

    Throng closing is such a shame but I wish you all the best for the future.

  • Guest

    !! BRING BACK THRONG!!! !!
    Upvote or comment below to get this show back on the road.