3 News

Here is a run down of the 5 most important stories on One News and 3 News tonight.  Please leave your comments on the bulletins in the comments below.

One News

1. Bronwyn Pullar goes public (Simon Bradwell)
2. US lead training in New Zealand (Michael Parkin, live cross, exclusive)
3. POAL locks out MUNZ workers (Lisa Owen, live cross)
4. New oil leak from Rena
5. Darren Hodges sentenced (Donna-Marie Lever)

3 News

1. POAL locks out MUNZ workers (Tom McRae, live cross)
2. Bronwyn Pullar goes public (Tova O’Brien)
3. Mourners farewell Foveaux Straight victims (Dave Goosselink)
4. Toulouse Police in standoff with shooter (Elizabeth Palmer, CBS)
5. Kim Dotcom gets $60k per month living allowance (Amanda Gillies) Continue reading »

Here is a run down of the 5 most important stories on One News and 3 News tonight.  Please leave your comments on the bulletins in the comments below.

One News

1. Nick Smith resigns from cabinet (Jessica Mutch, live cross)
2. Nick Smith resigns from cabinet (Heather du Plessis-Allen)
3. Dean Robert Miller in court on charges
4. Tama Iti returns home (Donna-Marie Lever)
5. Cost of Operation 8 (Lisa Owen)

3 News

1. Nick Smith resigns from cabinet (Tova O’Brien)
2. Nick Smith resigns from cabinet (Duncan Garner, live cross)
3. Looking back at Nick Smith’s career (Patrick Gower)
4. Toulouse police hunt shooter (Adam Hollingworth)
5. Mexican earthquake

Commentary Continue reading »

Adam Hollingworth’s story on 3 News tonight had new footage from TMZ of Kony 2012 campaigner Jason Russell’s naked meltdown.  However, he also included footage, which he prefaced by saying it had been broadcast on US networks, but was not of Jason Russell at all.

On seeing the piece, Matthew Holloway tweeted:

Continue reading »

Here is a run down of the 5 most important stories on One News and 3 News tonight.  Please leave your comments on the bulletins in the comments below.

One News

1. Prison closures (Sarah Batley)
2. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Lisa Davies, live cross)
3. Remembering those who died in the Foveaux Straight boat sinking
4. Jock Hobbs funeral (Daniel Faitaua)
5. Man dies in Christchurch housefire

3 News

1. Mount Cook Airlines grounds ATR 500′s (Rachel Morton)
2. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Dave Goosselink, live cross)
3. Dallas Reedy meets rescuer, Rhys Ferguson (Anna Burns-Francis)
4. Jock Hobbs funeral (Jim Kayes)
5. Fabrice Muamba collapses during FA Cup quarter final (Richard Pallot, ITV)

Continue reading »

Here is a run down of the 5 most important stories on One News and 3 News tonight.  Please leave your comments on the bulletins in the comments below.

One News

1. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Lisa Davies, live cross)
2. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Max Bania)
3. Chris Cairns match-fixing case (Garth Bray)
4. Staff Sergeant Robert Bales (Martha Raddatz, ABC)
5. Al Qaeda planned to kill Obama

3 News

1. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Dave Goosselink, live cross)
2. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Anna Burns-Francis)
3. Muttonbirding (Jeff Hampton)
4. Boat sinking near Raglan
5. Jason Russell hospitalised (Jenny Suo)

Continue reading »

Here is a run down of the 5 most important stories on One News and 3 News tonight.  Please leave your comments on the bulletins in the comments below.

One News

1. Dallas Reedy interview (Lorelei Mason)
2. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Max Bania, live cross)
3. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Lisa Davies, live cross)
4. Tana Umaga’s second cousin’s death (Kim Vinnell)
5. Urewera 4 trial

3 News

1. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Mike McRoberts, live cross)
2. Foveaux Straight boat sinking (Mike McRoberts, live cross)
3. Dallas Reedy interview (Rachel Morton)
4. Dallas Reedy survival (Michael Morrah)
5. Barry Bethune relives tragedy (Leanne Malcolm)

Continue reading »

Here is a run down of the 5 most important stories on One News and 3 News tonight.  Please leave your comments on the bulletins in the comments below.

One News

1. Somali man on stabbing rampage in Christchurch (Arrun Soma, live cross)
2. Teenager accidently shot doing homekill in Helensville
3. Port Injunction (Breaking News)
4. Prime minister announces super ministry (Michael Parkin, live cross)
5. David Shearer speech (Jessica Mutch)

3 News

1. Somali man on stabbing rampage in Christchurch (Hamish Clark, live cross)
2. Prime Minister announces super ministry (Patrick Gower)
3. David Shearer speech (Duncan Garner, live cross)
4. Urewera 4 case (Michael Morrah)
5. School bus crash in Switzerland (James Mates, ITV)

Continue reading »

Here is a run down of the 5 most important stories on One News and 3 News tonight.  Please leave your comments on the bulletins in the comments below.

One News

1. Future of Otago Rugby Union (Max Bania, live cross)
2. Remembering Jock Hobbs (Andrew Saville)
3. Conviction for former sports star who assaulted son
4. ACC privacy (Simon Bradwell)
5. POAL strike (Ruth Wynn-Williams)

3 News

1. Prime Minister accused of misleading (Duncan Garner, exclusive)
2. Future of Otago Rugby Union (Dave Goosselink, live cross)
3. Hip replacement recipients to sue (Rachel Morton)
4. Oceania resthome workers stop work meeting
5. POAL strike (Tom McRae)

Commentary

 

The ACC privacy story is a rather bad breach but I’m not entirely convinced that Simon Bradwell’s reporting on it was fair tonight. He reports, 

Whangarei Man, Alan Nicholas, was at home this morning when he got a phone call from ACC. But instead of giving their name, the caller wanted Alan Nicholas to give his, as well as his date of birth.

Perhaps Simon has never dealt with a bank, a government department or one of many other large organisations who hold personal and private information but generally speaking, if one of those organisation needs to get in contact with you and calls you, they will ask you to identify yourself so that they know they’re not talking to the wrong person.  I have experienced the exact same thing with the IRD and my bank on occasions.  To suggest this is bad practice by ACC when it is actually a safeguard used by many organisations as a way to ensure they’re not breaching privacy is not cool. I would suggest that this instance, had the call to Alan Nicholas been unrelated to what is one of the worst privacy breaches in New Zealand’s history, confirming his identity would unlikely have been a problem.

One News failed to credit the source of their story about Ports of Auckland worker Cecil Walker. They used images of the post from the blogger but ommited the header and name of the author.  Strangely enough, their online story clearly stated that the author of the story was WhaleOil.  3 News went in the opposite direction and interviewed the blogger, learning more about the information that had been leaked to him.

3 News had an exclusive that had footage of John Key telling the PSA that there wouldn’t be job cuts and that he wasn’t too keen on asset sales from back in 2008.  There have, of course, been two elections, a global financial crisis and the Christchurch earthquake since then.  Not surprisingly, Labour leader David Shearer was available for comment while the Prime Minister was not.

Verdict

3 News

TV3 has appointed Richard Sutherland to the new role of Deputy Director of News and Current Affairs.

Director of News and Current Affairs, Mark Jennings, says Richard is one of the most capable and respected news managers in the country.

“Richard is what we call a journalist’s journalist,” he said. “He is extremely well regarded for his news judgement and management style, and will add further strength to what is already a top-notch team.”

Richard Sutherland is currently Director of Coverage for TVNZ’s News and Current Affairs division.  Prior to TVNZ, he was the Managing Editor for SKY News NZ for three years, and his extensive experience in radio newsgathering includes five years as News Editor at NewstalkZB.

Richard will take up his new role in late April.

Here is a run down of the 5 most important stories on One News and 3 News tonight.  Please leave your comments on the bulletins in the comments below.

One News

1. Jock Hobbs dies (Andrew Saville)
2. Huge breach of privacy at ACC (Simon Bradwell)
3. Urewera 4 case (Donna-Marie Lever)
4. POAL strike (Kim Vinnell, live cross)
5. Death penalty a possibility for US soldier

3 News

1. Jock Hobbs dies (Hamish McKay, breaking news)
2. Syrian deaths (Alice Carruthers)
3. Huge breach of privacy at ACC (Adam Ray, live cross)
4. Chris Cairns libel trial (Melissa Davies)
5. Air Asia X ends service to Christchurch (Jeff Hampton)

Commentary

The death of Jock Hobbs lead both bulletins tonight.  3 News had it as breaking news although the story had been out for close to half an hour.

The ACC privacy breach is concerning.  While the breach happened in August last year, ACC were only made aware of it in December.  Now, in March, the public is made aware.

The Urewera 4, POAL strike and suggestions the soldier responsible for killing 16 Afghani civilians yesterday might get the death penalty were the other stories on One News while more carnage in Syria, the ongoing Chris Cairns match-fixing case and the end of Air Asia X’s flights to Christchurch were on 3.

The Urewera 4 case is regularly in the Top 5 for One News as the case continues while 3 News has had Chris Cairn’s case in theirs.  Which is the more important of the two stories?

Verdict

One News